By: Rebecca Schuette

You Don’t Own Your Competitive Narrative Anymore. Here’s How to Influence It.

Your next buyer may form an opinion about your company before ever visiting your website.

They’re asking ChatGPT to compare vendors. They’re reading AI-generated summaries of your category. They’re consulting review sites, analyst reports, and peer recommendations to build a shortlist.

And by the time they engage with your sales team, they may already have a pretty clear idea of where you stand relative to the competition.

That’s why competitive positioning is becoming even more critical in an AEO-driven market.

For years, companies have invested in SEO to ensure they show up when buyers search for solutions. Now, Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) adds another layer: How is your brand represented when AI engines synthesize information and recommend solutions?

But here’s the challenge: You can’t optimize your way into meaningful differentiation if you haven’t established what makes you different in the first place.

And you can’t assume that what your marketing team believes about your differentiation is what the market actually perceives.

Three Research Streams Every Competitive Positioning Exercise Should Include

At Winalytics, we believe strong competitive positioning requires triangulating three distinct perspectives:

1. The Market Scan: What does the market say about you?

Start by examining how your brand and competitors are represented across the information sources buyers use to evaluate solutions:

  • Your website and competitors’ websites
  • Analyst reports and industry publications
  • LinkedIn and other thought leadership channels
  • Third-party review sites like G2 and Capterra
  • LLMs such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini

The goal isn’t simply to catalog messaging. It’s to understand which competitive narratives are gaining traction, where competitors are claiming differentiation, and how consistently your own value proposition shows up across channels.

With LLMs increasingly influencing discovery, it’s also important to test how your brand appears in AI-generated comparisons and recommendations.

Are you showing up? What strengths are being attributed to your company? Where are competitors getting credit for capabilities you also offer—or potentially deliver better?

2. Internal Stakeholder Interviews: What does your company believe makes you different?

Your sales, marketing, product, customer success, and leadership teams all experience the competitive landscape differently.

Sales knows which competitors show up in deals and which objections are hardest to overcome.

Customer success understands what customers actually value after implementation.

Product knows where your capabilities are strongest and where the roadmap is headed.

Marketing knows the story you’re trying to tell.

But are they all telling the same story?

Internal interviews uncover both potential differentiators and disconnects. They reveal where competitive claims are supported by real experience, where perceptions diverge, and where teams may be missing opportunities to communicate value.

3. Buyer Interviews: What actually influences the decision?

This is arguably the most important input—and the one that’s easiest to overlook.

Interview buyers who chose you. And just as importantly, interview buyers who didn’t.

Focus on decision-makers within your ideal customer profile (ICP), because their perceptions are the ones that matter most to your growth.

What triggered their search? Which alternatives did they consider? What criteria mattered most? Where did they perceive meaningful differences? What ultimately tipped the decision?

Closed-won interviews reveal the value buyers recognize in your solution.

Closed-lost interviews expose competitive advantages, perception gaps, and potential weaknesses in your positioning.

Together, they help distinguish between the differentiators your organization wants to own and those buyers actually value.

Where the Real Insights Emerge

The magic isn’t in any one of these research streams. It’s in the gaps between them.

Maybe your website emphasizes security, but buyers consistently cite ease of implementation as the reason they choose you.

Maybe your sales team believes a competitor wins on price, but lost buyers describe a stronger perception of overall value.

Or maybe your company has a genuinely differentiated capability that customers love—but it’s virtually invisible in AI-generated vendor comparisons.

Those disconnects represent opportunities.

They help you identify the competitive territory you can credibly own, the proof points you need to reinforce, and the messaging that should show up consistently across your website, sales conversations, thought leadership, and AI-discoverable content.

AEO Makes Positioning a Business Imperative

AEO is changing how buyers discover and evaluate solutions, but it doesn’t change the fundamentals of why they buy.

Buyers still need to understand what makes you different, why those differences matter, and why they should believe you.

What has changed is how many sources shape that perception before your team ever enters the conversation.

The brands that win won’t simply be the ones that show up in AI-generated answers. They’ll be the ones whose differentiation is clear, credible, and consistently reinforced wherever buyers look.

And that starts with research, not optimization.

About the Author

Rebecca Schuette

Related Point of View Posts

Conversational Excellence and the Rule of Two Follow-Ups

Commit to this one simple rule and you will lead higher-impact conversations: In the age of AI, conversational excellence is a key skill differentiator. It

Read More

Conversational Excellence in the Age AI

In the age of AI, conversational excellence is a key skill differentiator in almost any role. Conversational excellence is a skill that just cannot be

Read More

Deciding Where to Deploy Humans-in-the-Loop in an AI-Powered GTM Engine

AI is changing the economics of go-to-market. Tasks that once consumed hours of a marketer’s or salesperson’s day—researching accounts, analyzing buying signals, developing content, personalizing

Read More